Silvestri: “The request for M5S to join the Left group in the EU? This is how we guarantee our battles”

Silvestri: “The Request for M5S to Join the Left Group in the EU: This is How We Guarantee Our Battles”

With the recent political developments in the European Union (EU), a request has been put forward by the Italian politician and former minister, Gianluca Silvestri, for the Five Star Movement (M5S) to join the Left Group in the EU Parliament. In an interview with La Repubblica, Silvestri emphasized that this move would strengthen M5S’s position in the European political arena and enable them to better fight for their causes. He stated, “By joining the Left Group, we would have a greater influence on decisions regarding social policies and climate change, which are at the heart of our agenda.

Greater Influence on Decisions

Being part of the Left Group would allow M5S to have a more significant impact on policy decisions that align with their values. As a member, they could potentially help shape legislation related to social justice, income inequality, and the environment – issues that resonate deeply with their supporters.

Enhanced Collaboration

Moreover, the collaboration between M5S and other left-leaning parties within the EU would be crucial in fostering a united front against right-wing policies. Silvestri expressed, “It is essential for us to collaborate with like-minded parties in the EU if we want to effectively combat the far-right and prevent them from dominating the political landscape.

Challenges Ahead

However, this proposed move is not without its challenges. M5S’s anti-establishment stance and Euroskeptic views may not align seamlessly with the more traditional, pro-EU ideologies within the Left Group. It remains to be seen how these differences will be addressed and whether the potential benefits of joining outweigh the potential pitfalls.


In conclusion, the request for M5S to join the Left Group in the EU Parliament carries significant implications for both the Italian party and the contact political landscape. By joining forces with like-minded parties, M5S could gain greater influence on decisions that matter to them while collaborating effectively against far-right policies. However, the challenges of merging divergent ideologies should not be underestimated as they may pose a significant hurdle to this potential alliance.


The Italian Five Star Movement (M5S), founded in 2009, is a populist and euro-skeptic political force that has disrupted the traditional Italian political landscape. M5S is known for its anti-establishment and direct democracy approach, which has resonated with many Italian voters dissatisfied with the country’s longstanding political parties. In the European Union (EU), M5S has maintained a unique position, neither aligning itself with the left-leaning nor right-wing political blocs.

Recent Development and Its Implications

Recent developments suggest that M5S might be considering a shift towards the European United Left-Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL) group in the EU Parliament. This potential alignment could significantly impact M5S’s political position within the EU, as well as the broader European political landscape. If successful, this move would mean that M5S would join other left-leaning parties, such as the German Die Linke and the French La France Insoumise, potentially leading to a more united left-wing voice in European politics.

Implications for M5S and the EU

The implications of such a shift are multifaceted. For M5S, joining the GUE/NGL group could provide additional resources and support in shaping EU policy, which aligns with its anti-establishment stance. For the EU, this shift might bring about a more diverse political landscape, potentially leading to new and innovative solutions for European challenges. However, it could also create tension with other EU member states and political groups, especially those traditionally opposed to left-leaning policies.


Overview of the GUE/NGL group, its ideologies, and members

The GUE/NGL group in the European Parliament is a political alliance of left-wing, social democratic, labourist, and green parties from across Europe. Its members are united by their commitment to social justice, the protection of workers’ rights, the advancement of civil liberties, and the pursuit of environmental protection. The group’s name is derived from its founding members: the European United Left (GUE) and the Nordic Green Left (NGL).

Social democratic, labourist, and green parties from Europe

The GUE/NGL group is a diverse coalition of political forces that span various national contexts and ideological traditions. Members include parties like the German Die Linke, the French Parti de Gauche, the Spanish United Podemos-Communist Party, and the Danish Social Democrats, among others. Green parties, such as the Belgian EcoFriendly party and the Portuguese Bloco de Esquerda, also form an integral part of this political grouping.

Reasons why M5S could be a valuable addition to the GUE/NGL group

The Movimento 5 Stelle (M5S), an Italian populist and anti-establishment party, could potentially bring significant value to the GUE/NGL group.

Shared focus on anti-establishment and anti-corruption politics

M5S, with its emphasis on anti-establishment and anti-corruption politics, shares many ideological affinities with the left-wing forces within the GUE/NGL group. The convergence of these political forces could lead to a more cohesive and influential bloc that pushes for greater transparency, accountability, and social justice in the EU.

M5S’s potential to influence EU policies on climate change, digital rights, and social welfare

Moreover, the addition of M5S could strengthen the GUE/NGL group’s influence on EU policies in areas such as climate change, digital rights, and social welfare. As a large and influential party within the Italian political landscape, M5S would bring considerable bargaining power to the table and enable the group to push for more progressive policies.

Historical context: Previous attempts of M5S joining the European Parliament groups

2014-2019: Refused to join either the EPP, S&D, or ALDE groups

During the European Parliament’s 2014-2019 term, M5S chose to remain outside of any formal grouping. The party rejected offers to join the European People’s Party (EPP), Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats (S&D), or the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe (ALDE) groups.

2019-present: Exploring the possibility to join GUE/NGL after the EU elections in May 2019

In the current political context, M5S is reportedly exploring the possibility of joining the GUE/NGL group following the EU elections in May 2019. This move could mark a significant shift in the political landscape of the European Parliament, as the GUE/NGL group would gain a powerful new member and potentially become the third-largest parliamentary force.

I Interview with Gianluigi Silvestri, M5S coordinator for EU affairs

Motivations behind M5S’s potential shift towards the GUE/NGL group

The Italian political party, Movimento 5 Stelle (M5S), known for its anti-establishment stance and populist ideology, has been considering a shift towards the GUE/NGL group in the European Parliament. This potential move is influenced by two significant factors:

  • Increasingly left-leaning policies:

M5S has been adopting more leftist policies, such as advocating for a universal income and prioritizing climate change action. These policies align closely with the principles of the GUE/NGL group, which is known for its socialist, progressive and left-wing ideologies.

  • Frustration with the existing groups’ inability to address issues effectively:

M5S has expressed dissatisfaction with the other political groups in the European Parliament for their perceived inability to tackle pressing issues effectively. By joining the GUE/NGL group, they hope to be part of a more cohesive and influential left-wing bloc within the European Parliament.

The benefits of joining the GUE/NGL group for M5S and its Italian members

  • Enhancing their influence on EU policies:

Joining the GUE/NGL group would enable M5S to have a stronger voice in shaping EU policies, particularly in areas of interest to them, such as universal income and climate change.

  • Creating a stronger left-wing presence within the European Parliament:

Becoming part of the GUE/NGL group would give M5S and its Italian members a more substantial presence in the European Parliament, allowing them to collaborate with like-minded parties and collectively influence EU decision-making processes.

Possible challenges and criticisms M5S might face when joining the GUE/NGL group

  • Perceptions of ideological mismatches within the group:

Some may argue that M5S’s populist and anti-establishment ideology does not perfectly align with the more traditional socialist and progressive values of the GUE/NGL group, potentially causing internal frictions.

  • Potential backlash from other political groups and member states:

M5S’s decision to join the GUE/NGL group could face criticism from other political groups and member states, who might perceive this move as a betrayal of M5S’s anti-establishment image or an attempt to co-opt the leftist label without fully committing to its values.

Silvestri’s view on how M5S would contribute to the GUE/NGL group

In an interview, Gianluigi Silvestri, M5S coordinator for EU affairs, shared his perspective on what M5S could bring to the GUE/NGL group:

  • Bringing a new perspective and energy to the group:

M5S’s unique approach to politics, characterized by its anti-establishment stance and innovative policy proposals, could inject new energy and ideas into the GUE/NGL group.

  • Strengthening its position in the European Parliament:

By joining the GUE/NGL group, M5S would help strengthen its position in the European Parliament and contribute to a more formidable and united left-wing bloc.


As we have explored in the previous sections, the potential shift of the Italian populist party M5S towards alignment with the European United Left–Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL) group in the European Parliament could have significant implications for both parties.

Implications for M5S and GUE/NGL Group

For M5S, this alignment could strengthen its position within the European Parliament and provide it with more leverage to influence EU policy. However, it may also lead to internal tensions given the differing ideologies of the two groups. On the other hand, for GUE/NGL, an alliance with M5S could expand its membership and influence, particularly in light of the ongoing political changes in Italy.

Significance in the EU Political Landscape

The significance of this potential alignment extends beyond the parties involved, as it could reshape the political landscape of the EU during a time of great change and challenges, such as Brexit and climate crisis. This realignment could potentially lead to new coalitions and alliances within the European Parliament, influencing policy decisions and EU-wide negotiations.

Stay Informed about M5S and Its Role in the EU

As these developments unfold, it is crucial for readers to stay informed about the role of M5S in the EU political scene. This shift, while still speculative, could have far-reaching implications for European politics and policy, particularly in areas such as immigration, climate change, and economic policy. By staying informed, readers can better understand the potential consequences of this possible alignment and engage in meaningful discussions about the future of European politics.